Dalal Street Investments

Apollo Tyres Stock Punctured – IDFC SSKI

January 7, 2008

IDFC SSKI in a report punctured the hopes of Apollo Tyres stock. The tyre industry is more of a commodity play with limited pricing power for players despite >90% capacity utilization. Though select players have hiked prices by ~1% in December 2007 in the replacement market to counter rising raw material prices, MRF’s non-participation raises doubts on sustainability of the price hike and rules out future increases.

SSKI recommends investing in tyre companies at PER of 8-9x with target valuations of 11-12x (both 2- year forward valuations). At 13.8x FY09E and 12.3x FY10E consolidated earnings, and 6.1x FY09E and 5.3x FY10E consolidated EV/EBIDTA, the stock appears fully priced at Rs 57. Given that there is currently no case for any material upside to growth estimates an UNDERPERFORMER rating is assigned to the stock.


Got something to say?